Airborne sound versus vibration: why the difference matters
Sound gets out of a room in two quite different ways. It can travel through the air, or it can travel through the building itself. Mixing them up is the most common reason a fix doesn't work.
Airborne sound
Airborne sound starts as pressure changes in the air. It crosses the room, reaches a wall, a door or a gap, and passes through. Anything that sits in its way and blocks air also blocks some of it.
The ratings sources use for walls and doors are built around this route. To eliminate airborne sound, the ratings source says all air paths between the areas must be eliminated.1
Structure-borne sound
This is the thud. A blow on a hard surface sends vibration into whatever the surface touches. The vibration moves along joists, studs and slabs, and a wall or ceiling in another room turns it back into sound.
The soundproofing source makes a strong point. Vibration through a structure, it says, is faster, more efficient and more readily amplified than airborne sound of the same starting strength.2
That explains the puzzle in the title. The bay seems quiet because your ears are in the air path. The room below is connected to the floor.
Why the fixes differ
Each route needs a different kind of change.
For airborne sound, you block and seal. Dense layers and tight gaps matter most, and the next page but one, on sound through walls and doors, goes into the weak spots.
For structure-borne sound, you break the link. The soundproofing source says it can be stopped by breaking the connection between the noisy room and the outside, and calls this acoustic decoupling.2 The ratings source agrees: it takes isolation that reduces the mechanical links between structures.1
The same source also says soft, absorbing materials are less effective against transmitted vibration.2 Foam on a wall won't stop a knock in the ceiling below.
Different ratings for different jobs
Wall and door products often carry a sound transmission class. That number is about airborne sound. Floors have their own rating for impacts. It measures how well a floor cuts impact sounds, such as footsteps.3
When you read a spec, check which kind of number it is. A good airborne figure says little about thuds, and a floor impact figure says little about a bang crossing a hallway.
A simple way to sort your own problem
Walk through these questions with whoever hears the noise:
- Is it sharp and clear, or low and dull?
- Do they hear it in the same room as the wall you share, or through the floor or ceiling?
- Does it change if you shut the door, or only if you move the mat?
Shutting a door changes the air route a lot. Moving or lifting the mat changes the structure route. As a rough rule of thumb, not a sourced finding: if the noise barely changes with the door, the floor may be the route.
What to ask before you pay for anything
Ask a seller or installer which route a product treats. If they say "sound reduction" and nothing more, ask whether it's for air or for vibration. Ask what test sits behind the claim.
For anything that means opening a wall, floor or ceiling, or changing how the building is attached, ask a qualified tradesperson. Structure is theirs to judge, not yours.
Notes and sources
- Sound transmission class, Wikipedia
- Soundproofing, Wikipedia
- Impact insulation class, Wikipedia