Floor vibration and the room below
A floor is a connected path. What lands on top of it ends up in the ceiling underneath, and that's true whether the blow came from a club, a ball or a heavy step. If the room below hears a thud, the mat is only the start. Not the end.
What goes into the floor
Three things push on a sim room floor. The club strikes the mat or turf. The player's feet shift and push during the swing. And now and then a ball or a club drops.
Each one sends vibration into whatever the mat sits on. If the mat sits straight on a hard floor, the blow goes straight in. The floor structure then carries it sideways and down, and the ceiling of the room below acts like a speaker cone.
The soundproofing source calls this effect a sounding board.1 That's why vibration can be heard far from the spot where it started.
A floor rating that counts impacts
Floors are rated for impact noise separately from airborne noise. The impact insulation class, or IIC, rates how a floor copes with impact noise like footsteps.2 A larger number means more cut.2
It's measured with a standard tapping machine and rates impact sounds such as footsteps.2 It may not match what a golf shot does to the same floor, so treat it as a rough guide.
There's also a field version for finished buildings. The source notes that field measurements pick up flanking transmission and other on-site conditions a lab test leaves out.2 A lab number for a floor type won't always match what you get in your house.
How isolation works
The idea is to put something between the source and the structure. One source describes passive isolation as using rubber pads or mechanical springs.3 In a floor, that can mean a soft layer under the mat, or a separation built into the floor itself.
For builders, the soundproofing source describes neoprene joist tape or rubber spacers between joist and subfloor.1 It also mentions resilient channels, which separate the drywall from the joists and reduce vibration transfer.1
Those are construction jobs. They involve the floor structure and the ceiling below, so they belong to a qualified tradesperson. Don't cut into a floor or ceiling yourself.
What to ask before you buy a mat or underlay
The questions below apply to any layer you put under a mat:
- Does the maker say what it reduces, impacts or airborne noise?
- Is there a test report, and what machine and floor type was used?
- Will it work with the mat's maker's own instructions, and does it change the hitting surface?
- Does it keep the mat steady? A soft layer that moves under a swing can change how the player stands.
Go with the maker's instructions for the mat and the stance. A quieter floor that changes footing isn't worth it.
Where the room is matters
A bay on a slab at ground level is a different case from one over a living room. Over living space, the floor is a bigger concern. Beside or above it, other paths matter more. For those, see the leaks page.
Renting? Check the lease before changing a floor. Rules differ by country, and by landlord, and a change you can't undo may cost you a deposit.
To tell which route you have, start with the air-or-structure split.
Notes and sources
- Soundproofing, Wikipedia
- Impact insulation class, Wikipedia
- Vibration isolation, Wikipedia