Where the noise in a golf simulator room comes from
A golf sim room makes three kinds of noise. There's the sharp bang of the ball, the dull thud that follows it, and a steady hum from equipment. Each one reaches your neighbors by a different route, so each needs a different fix.
The bang
This is the sound most people notice first. The ball hits the screen, and the screen and whatever sits behind it move and push the air. That's sound traveling through the air, and it fills the room in a fraction of a second.
How loud it is depends on the ball speed, the screen and the hard surfaces around it. The next pages go through each in turn. Why a ball hitting a screen is loud covers the screen itself.
The thud
The thud is different. When a club strikes the mat, or a ball drops to the floor, the blow goes straight into the building. Floors, studs and walls carry it along, and it comes out as a knock in another room.
A soundproofing reference says most of the sound that leaves a room does so as vibration through solid parts of the building, not through the air.1 It adds that a wall, ceiling, floor or window can act as a sounding board and amplify that vibration.1
That's why a bay can seem quiet to you while the room below hears a thump. You're standing in the air path. They're sitting on the structure path. The page on airborne sound versus vibration explains the split in more detail.
The hum
Projectors, computers and fans run all the time. They don't bang, but they make a constant background sound. In a small room it can add up, and it's the sound you'll still hear between shots.
Fan hum mostly travels through the air. Equipment that sits directly on a shelf or floor can also pass some vibration into it. If a vendor lists a noise figure for a unit, ask how it was measured and from how far away. How loud is a golf simulator shows how to read such figures.
The room itself adds to it
Hard walls, a bare floor and a flat ceiling bounce sound around. The result is reverberation, which is sound that lingers after it was made.2 A boomy or harsh room feels louder to the person hitting, even if the sound outside is no different. The room's own echo has a page too: echo and reverberation.
Two paths, two kinds of fixes
The routes matter because the fixes aren't interchangeable. A source on sound ratings says walls and ceilings must be designed with both the air path and the structure path in mind.3
Soft material in the room can help with echo. It doesn't do much for the thud. The soundproofing source says foam and other absorbent materials are less effective against that vibration.1
So before you spend anything, work out which noise is bothering someone:
- A sharp crack heard in the next room points to the air path, and usually to gaps, doors or thin walls.
- A low knock heard below or above points to the structure path, usually through the floor.
- A steady hum points to the equipment, and to where it sits.
- A harsh, ringing sound inside the room points to hard surfaces and echo.
Ask the person who hears it, if you can. Which noise they describe tells you where to start.
What to ask before buying anything
Look for products that say which path they work on. A maker that talks only about "noise reduction" without saying air or vibration hasn't told you much. Ask for the test method, and ask whether it reflects a room like yours.
Keep the swing space, screen distance and wall covering exactly as the maker's manual says. Quieter isn't worth a smaller hitting area.
Notes and sources
- Soundproofing, Wikipedia
- Reverberation, Wikipedia
- Sound transmission class, Wikipedia