Echo and reverberation inside the room
Inside a sim room the sound can feel harsh, even if little reaches the neighbors. That's an echo problem, and it has its own cause and its own fix.
What reverberation is
Reverberation, or reverb, is sound that persists after it's produced.1 A sound bounces off surfaces over and over. Each bounce is a little weaker, and the sound fades out.
In a small room with hard walls, a bare floor and a flat ceiling, those bounces come quickly. They blur together. The result is the harsh crack and boomy ring many sim rooms have.
What sets how long it lasts
The source says a room's reverberation time depends on its size, its shape and the materials it's built from.1 Every object in the room can change it too.1
That means furniture, rugs and a bookshelf all count. A sparse room with hard finishes will ring more than a furnished one.
Reverberation time is usually stated as a decay time, measured in seconds.1 A shorter time means the sound dies away sooner. If a vendor gives you a figure, ask whether it covers the whole room, and at which pitches.
What soft surfaces do
Absorbing material soaks up part of the sound instead of bouncing it back. The soundproofing source says acoustic panels can reduce the reflections that make the sound in the source room louder.2
So panels calm the room. The player hears less ring.
What they don't do
Careful here. Sellers sometimes blur this, and the difference can cost you real money if you buy on the wrong promise. The same source says open-cell foams absorb well across a broad range of medium-high pitches. Performance can be less impressive at lower pitches.2 Whether an impact is heavy in the low pitches is our guess; no saved source measures it.
And absorbers don't stop vibration in the structure. The source says foam and other absorbers are less effective against vibration passing through the structure.2 So a wall of foam may make the room nicer to stand in without making the next room much quieter.
That's the difference between treating the room and blocking sound. What does reach the neighbors is on the vibration page.
Placement near the hitting area
Soft materials near a screen or hitting area aren't a free choice. A real ball rebounds from whatever is behind and around the screen. Follow the maker's instructions on what covers the surfaces there, and on how far panels must stay from the swing and the ball's path.
Never hang something in the swing area. Check your swing with a club, with nobody nearby, before anything goes up. Fixings on walls and ceilings follow the maker's instructions, and structural work goes to a qualified tradesperson.
Questions to ask before buying panels
- What's the panel's absorption rating, and at which pitches was it tested?
- Is it fire-rated for the room it's going in? Rules vary by country and local code.
- How thick is it, and does it fit outside the swing and ball path?
- Is the claim about the room's echo, or about stopping sound leaving? Those are different claims.
If a product says it "soundproofs" and the evidence is only about echo, treat the claim with care.
Do it in a sensible order
Sealing gaps matters for airborne sound. The STC source says that to eliminate it, all air paths between the areas must be eliminated.3 Soft surfaces are a different job. The soundproofing source says foam and other absorbent means are less effective against transmitted vibration.2 Check each change with the same measuring method, as described under decibel figures.
Notes and sources
- Reverberation, Wikipedia
- Soundproofing, Wikipedia
- Sound transmission class, Wikipedia